Blind to the Risk: 4 Ways to Avoid Blindness from Dermal Fillers
A 5,680% increase has been reported in the popularity of injectable cosmetic treatments over the last 25 years — a trend likely to continue. One reason for this popularity is because they are seen as ‘non-invasive’, alluding to the minimal disruption to tissue when performed competently.
However, whilst the popularity of dermal filler treatments are enjoying an almost exponential increase, so are reports of attendant complications. Although rare, complications from dermal fillers can be devastating.
The most serious complications are vascular. Vascular occlusions can lead to necrosis (tissue death), scarring, and even more seriously, blindness. Indeed, dermal fillers have already led to 98 reported cases of blindness (Beleznay et al., 2015).
In a recent literature review (Beleznay et al., 2015), Hyaluronic Acid (HA, also known under brand names Restylane®, Hydrafill®, Hylaform® and Juvederm®) was the second most common type of filler associated with ocular complications, after autologous fat injections. HA is the most frequently used soft tissue filler in cosmetic practice.
Out of 98 cases of vision complications from dermal fillers, 65 led to unilateral vision loss, and only two cases of vision loss were reversible.
Injection sites at highest risk were glabella, nasal region, forehead and nasolabial fold.
How can dermal filler injections induce blindness?
The basic mechanism is fairly simple: central retinal artery occlusion.
If the tip of the needle penetrates the vessel, leading to an intravascular injection, and too much pressure is applied to the plunger when injecting, the arterial pressure can be overwhelmed and retrograde movement of HA into the more proximal arterial network can occur. Eventual embolisation into the central retinal artery will deprive the retina of oxygen, and lead to blindness.
How to avoid causing blindness with dermal fillers
“Soft tissue fillers are used for multiple cosmetic and therapeutic indications. Adequate clinician training in the use of these agents is essential for the prevention of adverse events.”
– Carruthers et al. (2015), Injectable soft tissue fillers: Overview of clinical use
1. The only way to avoid arteries is to know where they are. It may seem obvious, but all clinicians delivering dermal filler injections must have an in-depth working knowledge of vascular anatomy.
In their latest guidelines on qualification requirements for delivery of non-invasive cosmetic procedures, Health Education England (HEE) recommend that courses that teach injectables such as Botulinum Toxin and dermal fillers offer 50% theoretical training. This should, of course, include facial anatomy.
One of the changes made in Part Two (.pdf) of the recommendations (2016) was to raise the level of qualification requirements for temporary dermal fillers, so that no treatments are able to be delivered until practitioners have successfully completed a qualification at level 7 (postgraduate level), at which point they would only be able to practise under clinical oversight
2. Inject slowly and incrementally. In many cases of retinal avascular necrosis, filler was injected with too much pressure.
3. Inject to the correct depth and plane, taking into account the relevant anatomy of the skin, muscle, vessels and fascia.
4. Even with all of the above, no procedure is immune to error. You must have a management strategy in place, and be able to refer the patient immediately to an ophthalmologist within the limited window of opportunity to reverse the effect – after complete central retinal artery occlusion, the retinal survival time is 60-90 minutes.
Although a quick intra-occular injection hyaluronidase has been successful in dissolving the filler and preventing permanent blindness, there is no agreed method for reversing central retinal artery occlusion from fillers. Some advanced courses will cover central retinal artery occlusion, and advise using the latest medical knowledge.
Awareness of risks
Googling “risks of dermal fillers” brings up the following NHS summary:
So, with only superficial research, one might be led into thinking that beyond a minor risks, fillers are safe — regardless of who is injecting. Clearly, however, patient outcomes can be much worse.
Awareness of the risks should not only be more publically available, but also embedded in the regulatory systems of the cosmetics industry. With no formal qualifications or medical training requirement for delivery of dermal fillers, it is not surprising that some have denounced treatments like dermal fillers as a “crisis waiting to happen” (Keogh report, 2013).
“Anybody, anywhere, anytime can give a filler to anybody else, and that is bizarre”
– Sir Bruce Keogh, NHS Medical Director
Ultimately, only with proper medical training can the far more potentially devastating risks be minimised in the first place. Are you prepared for such a crisis?
Beleznay, K.,Carruthers, J. D. A.,Humphrey, S., Jones, D., (2015) Avoiding and Treating Blindness From Fillers: A Review of World Literature. Dermatologic Surgery: October 2015 – Volume 41 – Issue 10 – p 1097–1117 doi: 10.1097/DSS.0000000000000486
Carruthers, A., Carruthers, J., Humphrey, S., (2015) Injecting soft tissue fillers: Overview of clinical use. ©2016 UpToDate